X Fined €120m: EU Risks Clash with Trump

The European Union has levied a fine of 120 million euros ($140 million) against Elon Musk’s social media platform, X. The penalty addresses violations of the bloc’s strict digital regulations.

Announced on Friday, this move marks a significant escalation in the EU’s efforts to police Big Tech. However, it threatens to trigger a fresh diplomatic row with the administration of US President Donald Trump.

This enforcement action is the first financial penalty imposed under the Digital Services Act (DSA). The European Commission ruled that X failed to comply with transparency mandates. Specifically, regulators cited the “deceptive design” of its blue checkmark system.

Transparency vs. Censorship

The ruling has become an immediate flashpoint for transatlantic tensions. Even before the announcement, US Vice President JD Vance issued a pre-emptive warning to Brussels.

In a social media post, Vance argued that the EU should support free speech. He accused regulators of “attacking American companies over garbage.” Elon Musk publicly endorsed this sentiment.

EU Technology Commissioner Henna Virkkunen pushed back against these accusations.

“This decision is about the transparency of X,” Virkkunen told reporters. She asserted that the move had “nothing to do with censorship.”

The “Blue Check” Deception

The Commission began its investigation in December 2023. They concluded that changes made after Musk’s 2022 takeover compromised user safety.

Regulators found that the current system allows anyone to pay for a badge of authenticity. Crucially, X does not meaningfully verify the identity behind the account.

“This deception exposes users to scams,” the Commission stated. They warned it leads to impersonation frauds and manipulation by malicious actors.

Beyond verification issues, X faced other citations. The platform failed to provide sufficient transparency regarding advertising practices. Additionally, it denied researchers access to public data, violating DSA rules.

A Measured Penalty?

Under the DSA, the EU can fine companies up to six percent of their global annual revenue. Theoretically, regulators could have calculated this based on Musk’s entire business empire, including Tesla.

However, Brussels opted for a moderate sum relative to X’s influence. Virkkunen described the €120 million figure as “proportionate” to the violations.

“We are not here to impose the highest fines,” the tech chief explained. “We are here to make sure that our digital legislation is enforced.”

Geopolitical Fallout

The fine arrives at a delicate diplomatic moment. The Trump administration has signaled a hostile stance toward EU tech regulations.

A new national security strategy released by the White House urges Europe to abandon its “regulatory suffocation.” Furthermore, US Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick has linked trade discussions to the EU’s treatment of American tech firms.

Despite pressure from Washington, European leaders rallied behind the decision. France’s digital affairs minister hailed the move as “historic,” proving Europe can move from words to action. Similarly, Germany emphasized that the bloc’s rules apply to all entities, regardless of origin.

In a related development, the Commission accepted commitments from TikTok. The platform agreed to address concerns regarding its advertising system, though it remains under investigation for other issues.

READ ALSO: Venezuela Clears US Deportation Flights Amid Airspace Row